Gay teen Tim and his two best friends Laura and Brea spend their last summer before college grappling with their feelings about the fundamentalist Baptist beliefs of their families, and prepping for the Passion Play at their church. Preacher’s daughter Brea is having a crisis of faith while Laura quotes Leviticus to Tim. Tim draws strength from the support of his PFLAG Dad as he copes with the twists and turns of late adolescence — including a complex relationship with the church drama teacher who struggles with his own sexuality.

Nate is a 19 year old student and Margaret is a 52-year-old aspiring comedian. In spite of their age difference, they have a perfectly functioning friendship – that is, until Nate finds a new boyfriend and Margaret’s career starts taking off, putting their friendship on the rocks.